How can we invest ethically?

Hello,

I watch Finary’s videos with great interest, but I notice that they always talk about ETFs and PEAs. There are a few videos on how the rich and ultra-rich live, how they divert money, don’t pay taxes, circumvent, « optimize » and more. Moreover, with their wealth and power, they invest in things that increase our prices and make life less affordable for a large part of our societies. This segment is growing too!

Giving money to these people and their companies so they can continue on their path of destruction seems truly counterproductive to me. But they are everywhere. Every « green » ETF I’ve seen contains one of Shell, Tesla, Nestlé, Microsoft, Total, De Beers, and more. My confidence in the truthfulness of the claim to be « green » has therefore disappeared.

Enerfip, Lendahand, Trine, and other crowdfunding platforms are… acceptable but often they are concentrated in limited markets. Enerfip is focused on the French market, Lendahand is more diversified but Mexico is heavily represented, Trine has 2-3 countries that are always there, and the others I’ll skip. To have a diversified portfolio, it seems to me that you need to have multiple crowdfunding accounts, but crowdfunding is also a limited « market. »
Companies that are inventing hydrogen batteries, geothermal power plants, extracting water from air, etc. and doing so in Poland, Norway, Australia, Thailand, Brazil, and more are impossible for me to find.

So how and where can I find options to invest ethically and diversely without dedicating my life to it?

With your convictions, you’re going to lose money if you invest, so move along

4 Likes

This reminds me of the laws that the socialists just invented for us, like taxing dividends at 5% on companies returning more than 20% of profits as dividends. Often this logic doesn’t understand that if you do that, you discourage foreign investment and consequently impoverish everyone and local populations. It’s a bit like eliminating unemployment benefits during a severe recession—the budget gains in the short term, but you destroy the baker and you also penalize the entire local economy by deteriorating the quality of life.

As @Quentin122 tells you, the things you would be willing to invest in are hopes for the future, therefore highly speculative. These are things that burn through subsidies but don’t create value as of today. There are very speculative battery or hydrogen ETFs that I personally own, but you probably won’t like them either because you’ll find companies in them that you probably consider bad, like Air Liquide or Tesla. Yet these are the ones contributing to paving the paths of the future, even if it may seem harsh. We need them.

Otherwise, to answer your question, I heard about Goodvest life insurance in a podcast that invests in eco-responsible things. That might suit you. Otherwise, yes, I had also looked into this kind of thing myself and it’s either in private equity with other things, or not accessible at all.

Maybe ETFs on the circular economy would suit you:

2 Likes

It’s certain that right-wing policies haven’t impoverished anyone…

1 Like

Both are needed but with good sense; I actually highlighted two extremes in my post that lead to the same consequences.

An economy where you mix freedom and constraints is necessary. The difficulty is that what you call right or left strives to silence the other, when they are complementary.

The real debate isn’t right versus left, it’s liberalism or control, and when your doctor spends half their day transforming into a bureaucrat rather than treating patients, we’re clearly in control territory. You need to give people options that are superior to the level of constraints, otherwise you don’t produce Musks but Talleyrands, parasites who will be in every government :grin: I have a good current list if needed.

3 Likes

Hello,

Please, I know this period will lead us to talk about politics, but if you could avoid discussing it in almost every topic, that would be appreciated.

6 Likes

Hello,

This is a question I’ve also asked myself recently because, not wanting to invest my money just anywhere, I’m not investing it anywhere!

Everyone will have their own definition of « ethical. » For some, « green finance » is enough; for others, the capitalist system cannot be « ethical » for various reasons. You need to find your own path in this.

For my part, I recently started taking an interest in my finances, and my primary goal is above all not to lose money, so to beat inflation, and to do so by investing my savings in what I think is less destructive to the planet and society—that’s somewhat my definition of « ethical. »

Unfortunately, if you want to invest your money, being radical isn’t possible: there will always be a portion of your money that could finance things you don’t like.

For my part, I decided first and foremost to leave as little money as possible in my current account: banks earn money on this dormant money by investing it with the ECB, in treasury bonds, and therefore take a return that should go to you! Moreover, they can also use part of it to grant loans to companies you won’t like. It’s quite opaque, and unlike other investments where they’re required to produce activity reports, there’s nothing for this. Choose your bank carefully, perhaps by looking at certain published rankings that highlight those that still invest heavily in gas, oil, etc.

For now, I have a Livret A and an LDDS with quite a bit of money in them. I haven’t brought myself to abandon the Livret A, but even though part of it is earmarked for housing, for example, what they finance with the rest may also not please you.

I opened 2 life insurance policies:

GoodVie with Goodvest, with 90% in euro funds with only 3% in managed portfolios, in which you’ll find some funds with portions that won’t fully satisfy you. I’m mainly there for the euro fund, hoping they’re honest about what they announce.

I told myself that 3% is little, and the fund selection would be in line with the Paris Agreements, so a world at +1.5°C, with selection assisted by various specialist organizations. Again, everyone is free to set their « ethical » cursor where they wish, and to believe or not believe the discourse.

I also opened Linxea Spirit 2 with the climate objective fund and in self-managed mode this time. Same objective as before—it will mainly be on the euro fund. They also offer access to private equity funds specializing in infrastructure such as renewable energy; I put some money into it.

You can look at « labels » like Greenfin, Finansol, etc., which rate funds… but it’s not the ultimate solution depending on your « ethical » cursor.

In real estate, I identified 2 SCPIs that could match my « ethics »:

Kyaneos Pierre, which focuses on existing residential properties and renovates their portfolio.

Coeur de ville in bare ownership—they focus on downtown commerce, so presumably not large shopping centers on the outskirts consuming agricultural land. Be careful, it’s a very small SCPI; the liquidity risk is quite significant.

In crowdfunding, I have about 15-20% of my assets, and this is what pulls up my overall return. Mainly on Lendosphere but also Enerfip. Be careful—right now the photovoltaic/wind sector is in crisis because the government has halved annual targets, so select your projects carefully (look for those with a secured electricity sale price). Net returns ~ 4/5%

I’m also on Lita since this year on a few projects.

I also have shares with Energie Partagée, which offers tiny dividends, and they revalue the share each year. I’ve never sold, but it would give a return of around 2% net, I think.

I have participating securities with Enercoop; they’ll be remunerated at 3% gross, I believe.

I have social shares elsewhere as well to benefit from the ESUS tax framework, so I would need to eventually sell them to buy new ones if I want to fully benefit from the tax reduction.

I have a savings account and a term account with La Nef; it’s very (very) low-yielding. This year it will be well below inflation, but I like the projects.

And since I had excess cash while waiting to allocate it, I opened an account on Spiko for treasury bonds, so it finances the French state—that fits into my « ethics. »

Between what « loses » money (Nef savings accounts, social shares…), what doesn’t make money (Livret A, Spiko, participating securities), and what makes money (crowdfunding, maybe real estate someday…), I think I’ll end up 0.3/0.5% above inflation in 2026.

It’s necessarily not very diversified because it’s heavily weighted toward renewable energy, which, in my « ethical » category, is what needs the most financing since it’s infrastructure. But I know the sector well, so I manage to avoid unpleasant surprises.

Looking forward to discussing this topic

Very well, I won’t talk about economics anymore, or at all.

Perhaps the best thing would be for you to start your own business with your own money, your own convictions, clients who are like you, products or services that suit you, etc…

A business is the best investment until proven otherwise.

1 Like