Amazing documentary!

I’m quite surprised, not to say downright furious, when I see news programs doing reports on tenants who don’t pay their rent, stay despite court orders, and even negotiate an amicable settlement to write off their debt (sometimes €18,000 in arrears) plus an additional €5,000 to €10,000 to vacate the premises.

And calmly, real estate specialists approve and support this behavior, saying it’s better than continuing with a millstone around your neck!
Already few people were outraged by the fact that some tenants stopped paying, putting people who had taken on debt into precarious situations, and seeing some who, exasperated, took the law into their own hands and ended up being ordered to pay the tenant damages.

But this is the last straw, it wasn’t enough… now we’re going to create a real status for pariahs who will make it their business model: stop paying rent, squat, and negotiate a departure bonus to vacate the premises!
Then a new dwelling, a new standoff, etc…

For me, this kind of signal clearly doesn’t make me want to invest in real estate. And on top of that, with the new finance law, the status of private landlords is going to take another hit. I don’t know what they’re trying to achieve, but given that rates are going to reach 4% before long, the real estate sector is headed for very rough times in 2027

7 Likes

it’s clear that doing rental real estate to get 4% net after taxes with all the possible headaches and bonds that yield the same thing; the choice is quickly made

6 Likes

It’s high time we remember that the right to private property is part of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen and that it’s even the fundamental pillar of democracies.

Otherwise the king and thugs take whatever they want and it’s the law of the jungle. But in that case, if it’s no longer valid, we need to say so and give people the right to buy guns :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:

I’m a tenant myself and this kind of behavior is detrimental to all those who might not have 3 times the rent cost in salary but who pay the rent first.

In the same vein I saw a mother who had taken out 5 or 6 consumer loans to buy nonsense and they wrote off her debt, and a little old man with a 3000 debt and they told him no. Honestly it drives you crazy sometimes..

Obviously the woman started again after the report..

2 Likes

Or alternatively, do as I do: invest abroad.

In case of non-payment, the courts are notified, the police quickly carry out the eviction, and the tenant’s name is added to the bad payers’ register: good luck finding something else afterwards.

This puts the notion of property back at the center of the village, as well as that of responsibility. And when landlords have more confidence, they are less hesitant to rent, which leads to more vigorous competition in the market, thus normally preventing rents from skyrocketing. Everyone wins in this system, which is, all things considered… just logical.

5 Likes

The 4% vs bonds doesn’t work as a comparison: in rental property you borrow to buy an asset, the return on equity is much higher than 4%. Wealth is built with the bank’s money.

On unpaid rent, it’s mainly a market question. In a tight market with 20-30 applications per listing you can really screen tenants, rent guarantee insurance does the rest for 2-3% of the rent.

The real problem is more the 2027 Finance Bill on LMNP, that’s a real challenge to tax strategies.

2 Likes

I agree.

For operators, they have a file of bad payers.
Banks also file customers and they are banned by the Bank of France for several years.
Landlords, on the other hand, can only light a candle and pray that the tenant doesn’t say to themselves:
« Oh well, screw it, why pay my rent… I risk nothing by not paying the rent except getting richer! »

Landlords, on the other hand, have nothing left to do but light a candle and pray that the tenant doesn’t say:

Hmm, a landlord can absolutely request the last rent receipts, the last three pay stubs, etc.
After that, if this type of tenant (that is, reliable ones who pay on the dot) doesn’t apply for the property, one should ask the question of why?

The problem with this kind of report is that it only presents the extreme and probably biased version. Non-payments currently represent 3.5%

This should be put into perspective with the 2 million people living in « severely degraded » housing (NB not necessarily due to the landlord, and this doesn’t excuse non-payment except in certain specific legal cases)

3 Likes

You’re assuming that all tenants are of sound mind, but the financial statement doesn’t tell you who you’re going to end up with :grin:

That works for buying a car, not with humans. And it only takes one to mentally disgust you if you only have one property to rent.

You’re assuming that all tenants are of sound mind, but the financial statement doesn’t tell you who you’re going to end up with :grin:

Hence the tenant selection you can do which, while not reducing the risk to zero, allows you to reduce the risks.
If you only have bad applications, the property is bad.

I was a tenant and therefore looking for housing in Mulhouse a few years ago. My application is solid (permanent contract and more than 3x the rent), so guess which one I chose between a damp property where the wallpaper is peeling off or where the manager tells you « the landlord has planned renovations, » and a recent property in good condition?

The second was probably much less profitable for the landlord. Crappy properties attract crappy tenants.

In short, the numbers allow you not to stop at an isolated incident

2 Likes

The correlation is more in the rent effort that you have to make yourself. It’s something you also see in business, the customers you give great deals to are mega annoying, those who pay a lot hardly bother you at all.

It’s the same thing with rioting high school students since high school is free and prison with a get-out-of-jail-free card they’ll go set fires. If they had to pay for all that, they would respect it more.

This is France in 2026, and the French are asking for more :laughing:

Property being an inviolable and sacred right, no one may be deprived of it, except when public necessity, legally established, clearly requires it, and under the condition of just and prior compensation.

That’s not what is said, you also need to read the rest of the text which opens up the interpretation much more. One is deprived only if there is no public necessity.

And then there is also the article on freedom, that freedom which stops where that of others begins…

So in fact this property applies in reality fully only to owner-occupiers, not to landlords. It also avoids ending up with large landowners who already have everything and where farmers find themselves held hostage by this mafia of a few large landowners who own 90% of the land and are infinitely richer than the people on this forum.

1 Like

The problem with this kind of « except if » is like with values or principles, if you compromise even a little on a moral prohibition, it opens the door to everything.

So in fact this property right actually applies fully only to owner-occupiers, not to landlords.

Like he wasn’t using his car, so I wanted to do him a favor by borrowing it for 5 years?

It also avoids ending up with large landowners who already have everything and where farmers find themselves held hostage by this mafia of a few large landowners who own 90% of the land and are infinitely richer than the people on this forum.

That’s the full power of capital and the problem when you don’t have any, it creates an enormous gap between individuals, but this gap will always exist because we are essentially a capitalist species. I don’t know a single human being who doesn’t own the equivalent of a closet or a secret hiding place somewhere. That’s where respect for property rights is even more important, because if it isn’t, the great-great-great-grandchild won’t be able to benefit from the time and efforts of previous generations and will thus always be reduced to serving the local baron or Marxist who will decide what it’s acceptable for them to own or not.

We shouldn’t think in terms of class struggle, but as an ecosystem. If I own the land, it’s in my best interest for someone to work it for me and continue to do so. That way I can extract a portion of their productive effort. The problem you raised just before (the fact that farmers are « held hostage ») arises when the matter is no longer thought of as a team effort but focused on selfish interests. Even if economics can be summed up as that (everyone acts according to their interest), we need to find the point of convergence.

But I really enjoy the debates we can have here, it makes us think. And as for the answer to the question of how to prevent too great a disproportion between individuals’ capital, I don’t have the solution. But I’m certain we can find ones that don’t rely on expropriation. It’s a very interesting question that leads us to become a bit of economists ourselves.

Hello @Renaud61,

I understand that you enjoy debates, but this is a finance forum.
However, some of your recent contributions have been at times clumsy, at times disrespectful, and at times bordering on misinformation.
It seems problematic to me to say (on a public forum) about a woman who saves that she will be « good to marry » (even though I just saw that this message was hidden following community reports), to classify « good » or « bad » environmentalists according to your criteria, to stigmatize people in situations of over-indebtedness, or to associate without nuance « rioting high school students ».
Also, no « major » political party is proposing to abolish property rights, and we don’t need to know that your preferred candidate for the next presidential election would be Mr. Retailleau (who, by the way, talks about rolling back the rule of law, but let’s move on).

Your contributions on financial and economic matters, when they are sourced, are relevant. But this forum is not a political platform, and ideology has no place here, especially when it takes shortcuts that can make certain remarks hurtful or inappropriate.

Thank you in advance :slight_smile:

Allow me to add some nuance, I agree that the forum is not a political platform… But when you talk about investing, it seems difficult to me not to question economic policy: interest rates, taxation, wealth regulation, inheritance… none of these topics is politically neutral, nor is it for our investments.

At some point, if you’re on an investment forum, it’s because you believe that investing in stocks (or real estate) is useful, profitable, that it can help you prepare for retirement, etc. Consequently, you therefore believe in the market economy AKA capitalism (and the rule of law, I agree with you on that). Personally, I’m sometimes surprised to see certain anti-capitalist / socialist statements (traditional socialism, not the third-way social democracy à la Rocard/Schroder/Blair/DSK/Macron) on the forum, for me that reflects a clear cognitive dissonance.

3 Likes

Absolutely, the term « ideology » is poorly chosen, my bad. The short list in my previous message is more about specific points that fall into caricature or stigmatization and don’t contribute much of interest.

But yes, let’s debate the role the State should play in our lives or inheritance taxation, with pleasure! :slight_smile:

1 Like

The State knows perfectly well that these are empty words. Unfavorable signals for property owners have been accumulating for decades. The French love owning real estate far too much to carry out such threats. And since 99% of buyers can’t afford to leave their properties empty, they rent them out.

You only have to look at the number of young people aged 20-22 on this forum, at the beginning of their studies, who are dying to deal with all the paperwork and borrow at 4.5% over 20 years to buy their first property, when they could get better returns over that period with 10 times fewer constraints by doing a DCA (Dollar Cost Averaging) on the first world ETF they find in their PEA (Plan d’Épargne en Actions).

3 Likes

It’s hard to break free from the family advice they’ve been hearing for a long time. French financial culture revolves around real estate, not stocks. This doesn’t only concern young people, given the number of slightly older people on this forum who have built themselves a nice real estate portfolio. As my spouse says: with real estate, you can always live in it when things go wrong (but we shouldn’t repeat that to Ukrainians / Gazans / Aleppans / owners of squatted apartments / non-exhaustive list unfortunately…)

1 Like

I agree with that, and the real estate culture in France gives public authorities the latitude to do pretty much whatever they want. What’s the point of making this investment fiscally or legally attractive when they know that whatever they decide, the French will continue to buy and rent out properties.

It shouldn’t shock you that we say this to a young woman, who moreover appreciated the message in question. It’s a gentle compliment that highlights her perceptiveness.

If I have personally offended you in any of my responses, please accept my apologies: it was not intentional. And if you seem to harbor a certain animosity toward me, know that I feel none toward you.

Tell me that you disagree, that I’m wrong! That’s also the beauty of the connection that can unite us. If we all thought alike, our exchanges would be boring and we would risk sinking into a form of conformism where different thinking would no longer have a place.

As for the link between finance and politics, it seems obvious to me. I’m not trying to show you contempt, but I find it difficult to express it other than by saying it’s a bit like stating that water is wet. That said, we can naturally delve deeper into this question and devote considerable work to its mechanisms, even to the point of obtaining a Nobel Prize in Economics, like James Tobin in 1981: https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/1981/press-release/

Economics plays a role in many aspects of our lives, including in the analysis of criminal behavior and in the evaluation of penal policies. This is notably what allows us to study the deterrent effects of sentences, without assuming that a more severe punishment is necessarily more effective.

To add to this, the work of Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson and James Robinson, awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2024, demonstrates the importance of institutions in the prosperity of societies: https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/2024/press-release/

Finally, even Nobel Prize winners can be wrong. Solid expertise does not guarantee infallibility, and no model can anticipate all events likely to disrupt our predictions, or even our lives. That’s why I’m wary of absolute certainties. Karl Popper, Nassim Nicholas Taleb and the work on fallibilism invite us, each in their own way, to recognize the limits of our knowledge. This doesn’t mean we should doubt everything, but that we must remain open to the possibility of being wrong. I could source each of these ideas, but I also prefer to maintain a bit of spontaneity in our exchanges: we are human beings, not walking bibliographies.

Disagreement is not a threat. It is an opportunity to enrich one another.