I am a student with a sufficient source of income to live on for the next 3 years and I recently received a large sum of money. I have kept a portion for personal projects and I can invest 50,000 euros but I don’t know much about it. I can invest for the long term, and I don’t want to take too much risk (intermediate profile I would say). My banker (La Banque Postale) called me and advises me to put everything into life insurance that I have had for more than 8 years (euro fund + slightly riskier investments). But from what I have heard there are a lot of fees and I don’t really know how my money will be invested. I would like to make ethical investments.
For now I am therefore considering putting 20,000 into an ethical ETF (Amundi MSCI World SRI Climate Paris Aligned), and 30 into the euro fund of my life insurance.
I have several questions:
would a PEA be worth considering given that I don’t know much about it?
would a PEA be worth considering given that I don’t know much about it?
You’re considering investing in an ETF, if it’s available on a PEA you might as well put it in a PEA. However, I would add a nuance: research what an ETF is, what it contains, as well as the different wrappers.
are « ethical » ETFs really ethical?
The problem with « ethical » is that everyone has their own definition of « ethical » and criteria have been defined. Some companies are therefore considered ethical because they meet certain criteria. You might find companies you didn’t expect on your ETF - the first line is Nvidia followed by ASML, Visa not far behind.
Look at the top holdings of the ETF and form your own opinion on whether these companies are « ethical. »
does my investment idea seem viable to you?
I don’t know La Banque Postale’s life insurance product (but I have a negative bias), but look at the historical returns on BP’s euro fund and compare it to what’s best on the market (compare over at least 5 years). Talking about fees on euro funds is trickier because the returns given are net of fees, so it’s harder to compare before the return is announced.
Thank you for your responses, but in the long term, can ETFs really be risky? Actually, I’m in for very long studies (still 6 years to go) and I’ll probably have to move around during the first years of my working life, which means that I could potentially not touch this 20,000 euros for a long time. Otherwise, I’ve continued to dig deeper, at this stage I would like to invest mainly in Europe, and I found 2 ETF options:
Amundi MSCI Europe SRI Climate Paris Aligned with an online life insurance like Lucya (I believe it’s not available on PEA)
Amundi MSCI EMU SRI Climate Paris Aligned with a PEA
What do you think of these ETFs? Also, does it seem risky to you to put everything in Europe?
Hello Etienne, it’s great that you’re looking into this so early. It’s not easy to break away from your long-standing bank, but yes, you need to get away from La Banque Postale. They are not equipped to help you invest such a sum, nor to support you later during your studies and the beginning of your professional life. Which, after 6 years of study, should provide you with a certain standard of living.
The PEA (Plan d’Épargne en Actions) remains the best investment vehicle to date, and the ETFs you’ve suggested are OK. A broader one including the USA would be better, everyone will tell you that.
As for what’s ‹ responsible, › it’s normally verified and certified. However, there are always workarounds as with any standard. There are also specialized investment solutions for responsible investing (Goodvest being the most well-known).
If you don’t want to worry too much about it, consider managed investment for now. You can also diversify your investments and not put everything in the stock market. In any case, 6 years is enough to mitigate market risks.
In any case, get away from La Banque Postale. These banks are no longer suited to today’s world for individuals. And even less so for those who have savings…