Parking spaces: student loan or mortgage?

Hello everyone,

I’m 21 years old, currently in a work-study master’s program until summer 2028, in Montpellier. I’m considering a first small real estate investment to get started, and I’d like your opinion on the financing.

The project

  • A lot of 2 private outdoor parking spaces, in a residence in the Hôpitaux-Facultés area, near the tram.

  • A total budget of approximately €11,000 to €13,000, notary fees included, depending on negotiation.

  • An estimated rent of approximately €45 per space per month, based on listings in the neighborhood.

  • Condominium fees of approximately €74 per year for both spaces.

The two financing options

  1. A student loan at 0.99%, with partial deferment until the end of my work-study program, then approximately 10 years of repayment. The spaces would generate some income during the deferment, then the monthly payment would be approximately €40. Total interest cost: approximately €800.

  2. A standard mortgage, around 4% over 20 years. The project would be roughly self-financing from the start, but the interest would approach €5,000. On the other hand, I would build a mortgage credit history for a future larger project.

Assumptions: €45 per space, property tax estimated at €60 and insurance at €40 per year, taxation at 17.2% during the work-study program then 28.2%, no months without tenants.

  1. My questions

    • Which of these two options would you choose in my position, and why?

    • Do you have any feedback on renting outdoor parking spaces: demand, vacancy, unpaid rent?

    • For taxation, micro-foncier (simplified property income tax regime) or actual expenses regime from the first year?

    • Do you see any points of caution that I might have overlooked?

    Thanks in advance for your feedback.

Good evening Mahe,

I’m taking the liberty of answering your question, as being the same age as you (22 years old) and currently in the process of buying a garage box, I recognize myself in your situation.

During my research, I realized that it is much easier to add value to a garage box rather than an outdoor parking space, whether to attract a tenant or to achieve a potential capital gain on resale, for several reasons:

  • Usage and rent: A garage box protects against theft and bad weather, but also serves as storage space (this can be sought after by apartment tenants). The rent is also higher and above all I find that it’s easier to justify using a garage box to store your car rather than an outdoor space.

  • Legal security: The biggest risk with an outdoor space is unauthorized parking (squatting). Having a vehicle removed from a private space is really complicated (the pound doesn’t easily intervene on private spaces). With a garage box, the door and padlock partially solve this problem, although squatting is still possible but it’s then easier to remove the car.

  • Resale potential: The possibility of installing an outlet or charging station for electric vehicles (if approved by the condo association) can be an asset, which will become increasingly valuable on the market.

Regarding financing:
On paper, the Student Loan option is by far the best. The money is almost free and the deferral will allow you to build up a small safety cushion with the first rents.
BUT be careful, keep in mind that this loan may be complicated to obtain for your use because banks grant student loans to finance tuition fees, equipment…
Financing a rental real estate investment doesn’t fit within the product’s parameters.
But if you manage to make it work then it’s the jackpot for you!

Taxation:
Given your very low charges (€74/year) and the absence of work or large loan interest, the micro-foncier (micro property) regime will be the most advantageous. The standard 30% deduction will largely cover your actual expenses.
If you’re considering buying a garage box instead, the actual expenses regime is generally more advantageous.

(Below is the exchange I had on the forum regarding the purchase of my garage box)

Hoping to have given you food for thought :grin:.

1 Like

The 0.99% student loan is clearly the best choice if you can get it approved. For a mortgage on 12k€, it’s often not even feasible in practice: the fixed costs (application fees, guarantee) will eat into your profitability and many banks have a minimum threshold around 30-50k€ for a mortgage.

On vacancy: in the Hospitals-Universities area you’ll have solid demand, but if you rent to students watch out for the months of July-August. Healthcare workers are much more stable as tenants, prioritize targeting them if you have any in the building.

Micro-foncier is indeed the right scheme here, Paul is correct.

Thank you Paul for your very comprehensive response, and good luck with purchasing your parking space!

The point about unauthorized parking is very valid, I hadn’t considered it enough. I’m going to check if the residence is secured by a gate and if installing a barrier on each space is possible.

Regarding the student loan, noted. I’m going to present the project as is to my bank to quickly find out if it’s feasible.

For the taxation, we agree: with approximately €1,080 in annual rent, the 30% allowance largely covers the charges, property tax, and insurance.

I’m going to read your topic on the parking space, thanks for sharing.

Thank you Laurent for your feedback.

I hadn’t thought about the banks’ minimum threshold or the application and guarantee fees. For such a small amount, the mortgage quickly loses its appeal. The student loan therefore remains my main option, if the bank accepts it for this purpose.

Good point also about students during the summer. I’m going to target hospital staff instead to limit vacancy in July and August.

Do you have an idea of the average time it takes to find a tenant for this type of place in the area?

In this area with the university hospital and universities within reach, demand is solid. On LeBonCoin with good photos, it often sells in 2-3 weeks if the price is in line with the market. FB groups like « parkings Montpellier » can also speed things up. Some contact the CHU HR directly to post internally, which can be worth it to find someone stable quickly.

2 Likes

Hello Mahe

I’m 23 years old and I did the same thing as you a year ago

I bought, like you, a parking space thanks to a student loan at 0% interest! (just €2.70 insurance per month) with a 24-month deferment (Caisse d’Épargne, without being a customer before taking it out) — check out what they offer, it costs nothing…

If I were you, I wouldn’t tell the bank about your project. Personally they didn’t ask me for any proof of expenses and I withdrew the loan in one go (10k)