Which ETF in a PEA to avoid duplicate ETF in life insurance?

,

Hello everyone,

I would like to gather your opinions regarding the investment strategy for my PEA, with an investment horizon of 15 to 20 years.

I currently have a life insurance policy with BoursoBank, opened in 2023, in which I invest €50 per month in an Amundi MSCI World ETF (FR0010315770). Its current value is €2,483 for €1,900 contributed.

At the same time, I have a PEA with BoursoBank with four holdings:

  • Air Liquide: 14 shares, average purchase price of €141, current price of €169.

  • TotalEnergies: 24 shares, average purchase price of €55, current price of €78.

  • Société Générale: 25 shares, average purchase price of €29, current price of €63.

  • FDJ: 50 shares, average purchase price of €28, current price of €21.

My PEA therefore represents approximately €6,863, with an overall unrealized capital gain of approximately €1,444.

I am now wondering about the opportunity to sell all four of these holdings to invest in one or more ETFs, with a 20-year capitalization objective.

Given that I already have an MSCI World in my life insurance policy, I would like to avoid unnecessary duplication and favor coherent geographical and sectoral diversification.

In my position, would you keep these four stocks or would you proceed with a reallocation to ETFs? And if so, which ones and in what proportions?

Thank you in advance for your opinions and feedback from your experience.

Hi, why did you choose these 4 companies for your PEA? You must have had some convictions, right? The decision to hold or sell is up to you based on your strategy.

You also need to think about taxation, why did you get an AV? Is it for estate planning purposes? Because the PEA is more advantageous if you plan to withdraw money (after 5 years). On the other hand, the AV offers investment options that you don’t have in the PEA, if it’s just to invest in ETFs I would do it on the PEA instead.

With a World ETF in your AV, you’ll inevitably have overlaps since it includes everything. You could invest in Europe and emerging markets for example. Or in thematic ETFs if you have convictions.

1 Like

Thank you for your feedback.

I had initially selected these four companies with a long-term investment approach, choosing businesses I considered solid and likely to create value.

Today, my thinking has evolved. I’m questioning less the individual quality of these companies and more the relevance of maintaining a PEA concentrated on four French stocks, given my investment horizon of 15 to 20 years.

Regarding my life insurance policy, I wish to keep it, particularly for its tax seniority benefits and flexibility. My €50 monthly investment in the MSCI World suits me perfectly.

My real question therefore concerns the PEA: wouldn’t it be wiser to progressively or completely replace these four holdings with one or two broadly diversified ETFs?

Good evening,

Like many others, I really don’t see any benefit in investing in a world ETF on a life insurance policy rather than on a PEA.

And there’s no issue with duplicates. We think in terms of overall allocation.

I would keep the stocks you have, stop contributing to the life insurance policy, and continue investing in world on the PEA

2 Likes

Hello Julien,

You can perfectly invest in a PEA in a World ETF combined or not with emerging markets or even in the ACWI.

This is true even if you already have some in your life insurance (AV), these ETFs are broad, on the equity portion you are already diversified across 1,200 companies. Don’t consider this allocation as a duplicate but as a whole. If it’s a diversification concern, in the life insurance, it’s in other asset classes that you could diversify (Gold / Euro Fund / Bonds / SCPI…).

I agree with the others regarding your contributions, you would gain in returns by no longer contributing to the life insurance but by prioritizing the PEA. Except perhaps to secure liquidity in a Euro fund for short-term projects. What is the objective that prompted you to take out life insurance?

I also see that your World ETF is distributing, is this intentional on your part? What do you do with the distributions? Otherwise you also have this one IE00BYX2JD69 which is accumulating.

1 Like

The ETF I have in my life insurance policy is indeed accumulating. It automatically reinvests the dividends.

I will leave my MSCI World ETF in my life insurance policy, meaning without adding to it, to take out a new one in my PEA which I will contribute to. Is that what you’re saying? Thank you.

Yes. The total outstanding balance of your life insurance (AV), and therefore your ETF, is reduced each year by management fees, which don’t exist on a PEA. So unless you have a very specific situation and a full PEA, there is no benefit to putting in a life insurance policy what you can hold in a PEA.

1 Like

Hi,

I’m in a fairly similar situation (PEA, long horizon, DCA), so I’ll share what I’ve learned. This is not advice, just feedback from experience.

1. Selling in a PEA has no tax cost
As long as you don’t withdraw anything, a rebalancing within the PEA doesn’t trigger any tax, and seniority depends on the opening date, not the date of your purchases. So the only real question is: would you buy these 4 positions again today?

2. Your current portfolio is a concentrated bet

Four French stocks across four sectors (chemicals, oil, banking, gaming) is far from diversified over 20 years. For FDJ, the capital loss has no tax benefit in a PEA: keeping it to « break even » makes no sense, the only question is your conviction in the stock. Moreover, as Mounir often says, you’re probably already heavily exposed to France through your location or your work, assuming that’s the case.

3. The World in the life insurance is not a problematic duplicate
Think in terms of overall allocation, across all accounts. Having a World in the life insurance and in the PEA is the same exposure held in two places, not a risk but simply an optimization in terms of fees. The real duplication to watch out for is World + S&P 500: the World is already composed of approximately 70% US stocks, so adding an S&P 500 further increases US exposure. Personally I have both, but it’s a deliberate overweight, not accidental.

4. My experience in numbers
After one year of DCA on my PEA, I’m at approximately +€1,280 in unrealized gains on €11,400 invested, or +11%. The breakdown is telling: my World and S&P 500 ETFs are between +14 and +17%, while my France allocation (CAC 40 ETF and one individual stock) is roughly at zero or slightly below. And with DCA, this percentage underestimates the true performance, since part of the money has only been invested for a few weeks or months.

5. What I would do in your position

Two options, depending on whether you want to manage one or two positions:

  • Single position: the Amundi PEA Global MSCI ACWI (FR0014017NX3, 0.30% fees), launched in July 2026. It’s the first PEA-eligible ETF that covers developed and emerging countries together (approximately 10% emerging). You have the whole world, no duplication to monitor, and nothing to rebalance.

    • Two positions: a PEA-eligible World ETF as the core, approximately 85-90% (personally I use the iShares MSCI World Swap PEA, IE0002XZSHO1, 0.20%), and the Amundi PEA Emergent (FR0013412020, 0.30%) for approximately 10-15%. It’s slightly cheaper and you choose the emerging markets weight yourself, but you need to rebalance from time to time.

If you find it hard to sell everything at once, you can also keep the positions and direct 100% of your new contributions to ETFs until the stocks become marginal. But with €6,800 and zero taxation, selling in one go is simpler and cleaner.

Good luck. Over 20 years, the most important thing remains the regularity of contributions, not the first year’s performance.

1 Like

Hello. When investing, you need to think about conviction, diversification, and also objectives. Regarding objectives, putting 2 identical ETFs on 2 different accounts makes sense. A World ETF on your PEA and a World ETF on your AV. Depending on the age of your accounts and your projects, you can dedicate your PEA to short to medium term, for example, and use it as a liquid reserve, and your AV as a long-term account that you don’t touch. The inheritance objective should also be taken into account. It’s easier to pass on an AV than a PEA.

In short, you could even completely duplicate your PEA on your AV, it makes sense if the objective is well defined.

1 Like

The PEA is, on the contrary, the last account from which to draw: contribution limits are fixed (150k + 75 if PEA PME) and do not reset when you withdraw! If you start drawing from the PEA early, you undermine compound interest and the maximum limit without having fully benefited from interest compounding.

For life insurance, after 8 years it can be worthwhile to use it for liquidity, without exceeding the tax-free withdrawal limit on capital gains (4600/9200 euros of capital gains per year for a single person/couple). With modern contracts you can have the funds in 72 hours and you can very well benefit from a euro fund or other options as long as you keep a portion, which are more lucrative than the livret A.

That said, I understand the logic: you can withdraw from a PEA after 5 years without closing it, versus 8 years for life insurance to get tax-free capital gains, but it really wastes the main advantage of the PEA. You can always close it to open a new one, but it’s a shame to make the capital gains taxable in that case.

I would keep it, you have a nice composition. Rather than selling everything, you can consider reducing the weight of the allocation if you want to put more in ETFs.

For example

World ETF 70%

Total 10

Air Liquide 10

SG 10

I removed FDJ because they’re going to have a hard time getting back to 28. Keep the others because there’s a comfortable cushion compared to the average purchase price.

An even better solution than selling is to stop adding to your 4 stocks and redirect each new investment towards the world ETF. Mechanically, this will reduce the weight of the others. And it won’t cause you any regret when Air Liquide is at €250/share.

Thank you very much! And the duplicate ETW World in the PEA and AV isn’t an issue for you?

Not if you distribute the total allocation among each broker.

But it’s quite annoying to manage long-term. You should prefer simplicity when possible. But I’ll give you a trick to manage if you do it anyway, you’ll see it will simplify your life, it’s to manage your investments not by asset names or their performance but by predefined amounts according to the nature of an asset.

For example I have about €3500 in stocks on Trading 212 and I know exactly that it corresponds to €2100 in equity ETFs and 4x€350 in thematic stocks. Here tech is at €329 because tech got hit hard last week, otherwise normally it’s €350.

Here you also have a WisdomTree Physical Precious Metal which is an intruder, but by managing by amounts, my mind doesn’t even consider it, it’s just €500 in precious metals in my head and it’s in my precious metals column of my allocation, even if it’s on this broker.

When you manage by « asset nature », you can thus say I have €1000 stocks here, €2000 here, €10000 there (imagine it’s your same ETF each time).

For example for my commodities, I don’t even note the asset names anymore, I note this and immediately know what it corresponds to:

The 500 is the one you saw. So I know directly that it’s a basket of rare metals.

After that it’s a base, a guide, and the idea is to reinforce if we’re below, generally we always try to reinforce through contributions and not sales, and if it rises too much, we forget it in the calculation. So there if you want I should add €50 to precious metals but I’m doing nothing while waiting to see if it evolves downward or upward. If it’s upward, I do nothing :grin: and if it’s a drop below 30% same thing.

But if you want I have all the thresholds in mind and they already correspond to an allocation in percentages. You’ll be forced to manage in percentages or amounts if you have many assets because otherwise individually it’s hell. Hence the superiority of simplicity, if you have 3 or 4 assets, rebalancing through contributions or sales becomes child’s play. I reproduce the same process but by broker, world ETF + Danone in my mind is just = Stocks column > Bourso xxx €