ETF/Euro fund/Gold strategy

Hello everyone, I wanted to get your opinions on my current situation and my ideas for my investment strategy

  • Your profile: 38 years old, in a civil partnership, one child, 20-year investment horizon.

  • Your monthly savings capacity: €700

  • Your current assets: financial €82,000 + primary residence €110,000 (mortgage paid off in 6 years)

Emergency fund: €13,000

PEA (Plan d’Épargne en Actions): €28,000 allocated 75% MSCI World, 10% emerging markets (South America), 15% emerging markets (Asia)

Life Insurance: €8,500 euro fund

PEE (Plan d’Épargne Entreprise): €11,000: used to reduce taxes on bonuses, I withdraw as soon as I can to invest in PEA/life insurance

PER (Plan d’Épargne Retraite): €14,000 opened when I started working, not relevant to my profile, but impossible to close, I only put world ETFs in it

Gold €7,500

  • Your objectives: main objective: retirement supplement, but potentially emergency reserve if I lose my job (threatened by AI I think)

  • Your risk tolerance: I started investing 2 years ago, so haven’t experienced a major crisis yet but I would say I’m fairly risk-tolerant

  • Your main question: Opinion on my strategy (see just below) and the integration of SCPI (Société Civile de Placement Immobilier)

Personal conviction: regardless of the type of stock market crash, it will always eventually recover, and it’s impossible to know when a crash will happen, so you need to have a resilient portfolio to have room to maneuver.

My strategy: given my long investment horizon, lots of stocks (approximately 76%) I consider my PEE and my PER as stocks even if in reality it’s not only that, but it simplifies my monthly tracking.

I really like this asset class for the usual reasons, returns, ease of investment, passivity, and I try to limit its major flaw (volatility) with the following 2 asset classes:

Gold (approximately 11%): also volatile but uncorrelated with the stock market

Euro fund (approximately 13%): helps further limit volatility

These 2 asset classes therefore serve to limit volatility when the economy is doing well, and serve as « ammunition » in case of crisis:

I plan to sell part of these 2 asset classes when stocks fall, for example sell 20% when stocks are down 20%, sell 30% if they fall by 30% (for example), which allows me to sell gold with a capital gain (if it rises in case of crisis) to buy cheap stocks.

This rebalancing will be done in the life insurance, in order to avoid paying tax, and once the crisis has passed I will resell part of the ETFs to rebuild my defensive pocket

Your opinion on this strategy with these 3 asset classes and their roles?

Another point: SCPI, I really appreciate this asset class for the following reasons: decent returns, low volatility, possibility to buy on credit, transfer bare ownership later to my child.

In my retirement strategy it’s an important asset class (30% target) for a less volatile portfolio and to have a regular income supplement.

My initial plan was to wait for the end of my mortgage in 6 years, to buy approximately €40,000 on credit (8 years) and use leverage. Reasonable amount, not too long duration but long enough to benefit from leverage, European SCPI only (Corum Origine, Iroko Zen, Remake Live, etc.)

Now I’m considering a more modest loan early next year (a Younited / Corum offer) for a 5-year loan at 2.9%, €12,000

Objective: « test » SCPI with a modest amount

given their long-term nature, I tell myself that buying as early as possible is a good idea

I have a slight concern about my job, so start investing in SCPI to finish paying off this first loan fairly quickly

once this loan is paid off, the rent received can finance part of the larger SCPI loan in 6 years

Disadvantage: lower returns than ETFs, so perhaps too early as a purchase?

this loan offer only works for Corum, I can’t diversify with other SCPI

thanks in advance for your feedback!

>Your opinion on this strategy with these 3 asset classes and their roles?

Why not? In principle, it doesn’t seem unreasonable to me.

What I would mainly question is the fact that the assets seem to be distributed across several wrappers, which can complicate rebalancing. It’s therefore important to carefully anticipate the different rebalancing scenarios and the liquidity and tax impacts.

The other question is whether you consider gold and the euro fund as ammunition to deploy when certain drops occur, or whether you’re instead looking to maintain a target allocation between assets with a predetermined rebalancing schedule.

I’m from the second school of thought, which is the most systematic in approach, but the first is defensible if it’s well-structured.

As for the question about SCPIs (Sociétés Civiles de Placement Immobilier), I’ll pass as it’s not my cup of tea.

Thank you for your feedback

The rebalancing will be done on the life insurance

There is gold and the euro fund

So I will make transfers to buy MSCI World, I know I will pay annual management fees but it will save me from withdrawing money from the insurance to put into the PEA, and withdrawing from the PEA at the end of the crisis to buy back gold and euro fund

For the 2nd point I distinguish 2 scenarios: normal economy, I use my DCA to maintain the balance between the 3 asset classes and if needed I do a more significant rebalancing at the end of the year

2nd scenario: crisis, in this case all my DCA will be for stocks, and I will make the transfers explained before

Hello John,

Regarding your PER, you made the right allocation choice. Taking dynamic assets will maximize your tax deferral. Be careful to only contribute the portion of your income in the 30% bracket. Below that, the tax leverage is not high enough to make this wrapper advantageous compared to other investments.

Like Emi, I’m not at all attracted to SCPIs. Too much uncertainty about returns, too many fees, not liquid and too complex. This type of investment makes you very dependent on management companies. I prefer to invest in stocks and balance with Euro funds or bonds (if long-term vision). Moreover, being the owner of my primary residence, I’m already indirectly heavily invested in real estate (60% of my capital in fact). OK, it doesn’t generate income for me, but it saves me from paying €1,300 in rent. That’s mainly how I see it.

Thank you for your feedback

I didn’t specify but I won’t be contributing anything more to the PER, it’s more of an old investment that’s sitting there and that I can’t close, so I’m trying to make the best use of it

Indeed if one day I exceed the 30% tax bracket, I’ll use it but I don’t think that will happen

SCPI I have the same concern about the management companies, I was thinking of applying the following rule: each SCPI should not exceed 5% of all my investments

So if I have a total of 4 SCPIs in my allocation, I should have 4 different SCPIs

That way if a management company fails and loses 50% it would represent a loss of 2.5% of my capital (half of 5%)

That would limit the problem a bit I hope

My primary residence doesn’t factor into my strategy for growing my financial wealth, even though I understand the idea of saying that it’s money that’s in real estate

Hello John,

Good catch on the PER. It remains to be seen whether the fees won’t drag down your returns in the long term. You can transfer it if you find that they are too high.

Regarding SCPIs, my knowledge of this asset is limited. That said, your strategy is interesting, so I ran your message through AI to learn more about your idea. To avoid cluttering the forum with AI content, I won’t post its analysis. But some of its warnings prompt me to encourage you to do the same.

AI aside, my personal view is that your current strategy seems quite balanced. Your equity exposure doesn’t concern me given your long-term strategy, your emergency fund, and your secure allocation. Regarding your employment, if unfortunately things go wrong, your PEE can be unlocked and your PER can also be unlocked, but only at the end of your unemployment benefits. Without considering these two accounts as emergency savings, knowing these rules gives you additional room to bounce back. Be careful about the idea of Gold/Equity arbitrage—their valuations are not always uncorrelated. And finally, my biggest concern is regarding your desire to invest in SCPIs. Incorporating an income strategy almost 20 years before your consumption horizon seems premature. This involves fees, limited liquidity, and additional real estate risk, with no guarantee of improving your overall performance. Personally, I would favor your current strategy, especially since your PEA is not maxed out. That’s why I strongly encourage you to consult with an AI to inform your choices and take the time to think about incorporating SCPIs. Be careful with AI though—verify its claims before making a firm decision.

Thanks for the feedback

Yes indeed I transferred the PER to boursobank (it was with axa), I left it in managed mode for now and from what I’ve seen they use ETFs to replicate the msci world basically (a US ETF, Europe, and Japan)

SCPIs would bring me stability I think, even if indeed the return will probably be lower than ETFs, but I might wait 6 years to no longer have any credit and potentially buy SCPIs on credit at that time.

8-year loan, the rental income during this period will be used to pay part of the monthly payments, and afterwards I’ll have a small additional income.

So in 14 years (6+8 years) in this example which is not bad