Strategy for integrating €10,000 LQQ into Bourso PEA

,

Hello,

I’m giving you an update on my PEA. I started investing in it at the beginning of this year. I’m 53 years old and my time horizon is approximately 9 years before the start of the withdrawal phase, which should last 7 years.

Today, my PEA has reached €61,700, including €5,700 in capital gains, after a small lump sum and the implementation of an accelerated DCA of €2,000 every two weeks, funded by part of my Livret Bourso+.

Regarding ETFs, I’ve chosen:

  • MSCI World: WPEA, then DCAM since the change on 05/10;

  • Emerging markets: PAEEM.

I alternate contributions to simplify the DCA and maintain a target allocation of 80% World / 20% emerging markets.

For my accelerated DCA, my initial plan was to continue contributing €2,000 every two weeks this year, then €1,000 every two weeks next year to these two ETFs.

I’m now considering adding a small allocation of LQQ to boost the portfolio’s potential return. I’m aware that this is a daily leveraged ETF and that the risk is significantly higher than that of my standard ETFs.

Here’s the strategy I’m considering implementing starting next month.

1. Building the LQQ allocation

I would allocate €500 per month of my investment effort to LQQ, until reaching €10,000 in cumulative contributions, potentially 20 months.

2. Progressive recovery of the initial investment

If the allocation’s valuation reaches the following thresholds, I would progressively sell €2,000 worth of shares at each level:

  1. LQQ allocation at €17,000: sell €2,000;

  2. LQQ allocation at €22,000: sell €2,000;

  3. LQQ allocation at €27,000: sell €2,000;

  4. LQQ allocation at €32,000: sell €2,000;

  5. LQQ allocation at €37,000: sell €2,000.

If all thresholds are reached, I will have thus recovered the €10,000 initially invested. I would then keep the remaining balance of the position to benefit from a potential continued uptrend, while knowing that the remaining capital would still be exposed to the risk of loss.

The objective is therefore to progressively recover my initial investment if the thresholds are reached, not to guarantee the capital.

I conducted an initial backtest starting from October 2017 (DCA €500 on the first business day of each month for 20 months + withdrawals when thresholds are reached). With these rules, the simulation results in the complete sale of my investment in October 2024 (5th threshold) and capital of approximately €60,000 today, despite the Covid episodes and the 2022 decline. I’m aware that the result depends on the period studied and that other scenarios should be tested.

My questions:

  1. What do you think of this strategy of adding LQQ with progressive recovery of the initial investment?

  2. For purchases, is it better to integrate LQQ into my DCA or try to time the entries?

  3. Do you see any significant risks or biases in my tiered selling method?

  4. I’ve selected LQQ, but would other leveraged ETFs be available on PEA at Bourso (Boursorama)?

Thank you in advance for your feedback.

9 years until your consumption phase is already risky to be in equity ETFs, in the sense that if you take a -40% hit 1 year before, you won’t be able to consume the capital. And you also have currency risk.

With a leveraged ETF you can take a -90% hit. Or just with a market that stagnates over several years, a -15-20% minimum compared to X1.

In short, it’s not at all suitable, it’s not investing but gambling.

You should rather think about how to de-risk your portfolio as the deadline approaches.

The only case where LQQ could be an opportunity, even if not without risk either, is to enter after a major correction on the X1. Even if it can always go lower, but at least you’re taking much less risk that way.

2 Likes

You’re right, I should have specified that in the message.

My invested assets currently amount to €230,000. Overall, I have:

  • 20% in secure investments (Savings accounts + Euro funds)
  • 15% diversified (Gold / commodities)
  • The rest in Stocks

My objectives are retirement supplement for my PEA and PER for 7 years, after which I will progressively transfer the surplus to life insurance policies.

And then the transmission objective to my designated beneficiaries for my life insurance policies.

The retirement supplement part is a bonus, I own my primary residence. My estimated retirement pension should be sufficient on its own without extravagance if the market is in a prolonged downturn.

Regarding the PEA, it’s just about modifying the contribution plan originally envisioned:

  • €120,000 World ETF
  • €30,000 EM ETF

Instead there would be:

  • €110,000 World ETF
  • €30,000 EM ETF
  • €10,000 LQQ ETF

Subsequently, if all thresholds are reached, progressive sale of the contribution to reinvest in World ETF. The idea then is to let the LQQ run for the entire duration of my PEA. I’m well aware that I’m risking the €10,000 in the early years. That said, it needs to be put in perspective because this amount isn’t even 5% of my invested assets.

If the next 9 years are strictly identical to the last 9, which is by no means guaranteed, that would give you an additional gain of less than 10,000 euros, gross. Nothing revolutionary, but why not.

The main question, however, is the connection to the overall strategy and its robustness. You seem generally very rushed, with a more medium-term than long-term investment horizon, a very short consumption period. So with a very high sequence risk.

When approaching your endpoint, you usually remove risk rather than add it. Unless these 9 years and then these 7 years are actually « negotiable, » which changes the investment thesis.

Regarding leveraged instruments in PEA, there are indeed alternatives, CL2 and LWLD. Both have a better risk/return ratio than LQQ.

« If all thresholds are reached, I will have thus recovered the 10,000 € initially invested. »

And if the thresholds are not reached?

This is not very good risk management because you’re letting your exposure to LQQ potentially balloon without any guarantee of actually recovering your initial amount. It would probably be much wiser and simpler to set an allocation weight for LQQ (with a small tolerance) and rebalance the portfolio accordingly, or even define a decreasing exposure cap rather than a weight. And even given the time horizon, to progressively reduce the weight of LQQ. Because if LQQ rises significantly, it also represents a growing portion of your wealth. And you don’t necessarily have much time ahead in case of a decline. It’s a double-edged sword.

Your backtest is over a very favorable period. Take the complete history of the NASDAQ 100, it becomes more of a roller coaster. Don’t forget that a backtest only gives us one past trajectory, not the future trajectory.

1 Like

Hello Equinox, thank you for your informative feedback.

Indeed, as someone who likes working with numbers, I haven’t compared the potential gain versus keeping my current PEA allocation of 80% MSCI World / 20% Emerging Markets. Is that what you’re referring to regarding the 10,000 €?

I started investing this year at 53 years old, I can’t really push it much further. My retirement is normally planned for 62 years old.

For the 7 years, my goal is to quickly sell my PEA and my PER for consumption and transfer to the life insurance before I turn 70. Having no direct heirs, my secondary objective is to pass on what remains to my nieces and nephews by heart (blended family) with the least possible fees.

Thank you for the ETFs, I’ll look into that.

« The stock market is a mechanism for transferring money from the impatient to the patient » Buffett

The QQQ is a bit like Russian roulette, I would set myself a percentage not to exceed. Given your time horizon, if there’s a crash it’s going to be very complicated

Hello Emi,

Indeed that’s possible, which is why I want to deliberately limit my exposure to €10,000 of investment.

Yes, your idea is interesting. If LQQ rises strongly, I could indeed reallocate part of it. But by then there’s already a strong chance that I’ll already be in the consumption period. It’s already somewhat what I’m doing with my thresholds. I could indeed continue beyond €37,000.

LQQ starts in 2006, I had thought that COVID and 2022 at the beginning already made a good model with two successive declines at the most critical moment.

I just redid it by investing from 02/2007 just before 2008. The buyback period is longer, but it ends in 03/2015. And I finish the investment period (the 9 years) with €32,000 instead of the €60,000 in the first simulation. It’s true that it varies greatly and yet it remains feasible.

Yes, you’re right on target. That’s why I’m limiting it to €10,000 invested. That’s only 4% of my liquid capital (excluding primary residence). In short, enough to stay low enough not to keep me up at night if I lose everything.

The idea was precisely to boost the return on my PEA a bit because my time horizon is short. All the opinions are unfavorable toward leveraged ETFs for my profile. So I’m going to give myself some time first to compare the difference between leaving the DCA as initially planned and the €10,000 in LQQ.

Backtest on the complete Nasdaq history with a recreated x2. Note the very long underwater period of over 20 years for the x2 despite the good performance over the entire history. You have relatively few years to amortize this risk.

We need to see whether what’s at issue is the profile, or the strategy.

One of the 2 stated objectives is succession, potentially with a 30-year time horizon. That changes everything.

One possibility is to start this succession portion today with an LWLD directly in life insurance.

We need to be careful that the pressure of tax deadlines doesn’t compete too much with the capitalization and compounding process. Capital compounding requires time. A strategy that doesn’t allow itself time will generally be inferior.

Yes, it was a quick simulation of the difference.

Thanks for the chart. On my end, I just compared with the same amount on an MSCI World. Indeed, if all goes well, I make €30,000 more until the drawdown period. I haven’t looked beyond that, but withdrawals will begin. This amount won’t change my life. So is it worth risking €10,000? Not certain.

Thanks to everyone for your contributions

That’s an option I hadn’t thought of. My life insurance (Linxea Spirit 2) offers LWLD as well.

Thanks for the idea.

It doesn’t seem like a bad idea for the short term and the last 5 years prove it right, but you have to play it safe in case of an AI crisis. So small allocation, because here a stop won’t be very useful if something happens in the USA and it drops -10x2 the next day.

Thank you Renaud,

Otherwise, I do indeed have the alternative proposed by @Equinox. Rather take LWLD in my Linxea Spirit 2. I’ll keep the idea of €500/month over 20 months. And then I let it run, a World x2 will potentially be less concentrated than a Nasdaq.

The advantage is that I have more time with the life insurance policy (potentially my entire life). And my PEA remains simple. The other advantage is that it’s placed in the same wrapper as the gold and commodities that I had taken on it thanks to your advice. In case of a drop or sharp increase, arbitrages between uncorrelated assets could be carried out more easily.

1 Like

There is one scenario where gold won’t work this way, and that’s during phases of extreme market stress (like in March 2020), when investors face margin calls or need to urgently close positions to recover cash.

Result: they sell everything that has value, including gold. During these liquidity crisis periods, the correlation between stocks and gold tends toward 1 and both fall simultaneously.

Dollars then have the most value because it’s the most reputable solid cash in the world, but on spirit 2 I checked and there’s nothing, what there is like treasury 1-3 yr is hedged on the euro so it cancels out the effect.

1 Like

Thank you for the response. Not as simple as I thought then.

Yes, but in the long term, gold always wins because its value is invariable. So people always return to it when they fear their state’s monetary policies.

That’s why one of the worst things a country can do is sell its gold. Because if you’re French and you know nothing about Zimbabwe, you’re going to ask not to be paid in local currency but in gold.

Cash is a debt of the state, if your state isn’t very reliable, you’re going to seek to convert your currency into something more secure, and there comes gold.

1 Like

In a long-term strategy, the only thing I would see performing would be fixed rebalancing, by 20% bands or by period (semi-annual, annual) within a diversified allocation. In this case, we can reap the benefits of good years and reload during years when things go wrong.

Taking LQQ while telling yourself you’ll lighten up if you make x2 x3 x4 seems optimistic to me. We have a situation not far from the 2000 internet bubble, when the Nasdaq dropped -80%, LQQ would have dropped close to -98%. The risk of never reaching these thresholds is high, and mechanical rebalancing seems more likely to take advantage of Nasdaq volatility.

In any case, that’s how I set up a long-term strategy on PER (Plan d’Épargne Retraite): no rebalancing costs other than order fees in AV (Assurance Vie).

That said, over a 9-year horizon, it seems generally risky to take LQQ. LWLD or momentum would surely be more suitable to avoid being too far underwater.

Thank you,

Indeed, thanks to the community’s advice, I dropped this idea.