Loan request for a primary residence --> Conversion to rental investment

Hello,

I would like to hear from people here who have applied for a mortgage (without PTZ or other assistance, obviously) by presenting it to the bank as a primary residence purchase when it was actually a rental investment (mainly to bypass the HCSF’s 35% debt-to-income ratio limit).

I’ve seen this « scheme » mentioned several times in forum topics and I was wondering what the potential consequences could be before potentially doing it myself.

It’s done, but the risks are not negligible.

The biggest one: acceleration clause. If the bank discovers that you’re renting it out (through your tax return the following year, water damage where your tenant files an insurance claim, or a simple verification), they can demand immediate repayment of the entire remaining principal.

Criminally, it’s theoretically fraud, but in practice prosecutions are very rare for this type of case.

The real question: why are you stuck on the debt-to-income ratio? If it’s because rental income isn’t being taken into account, some banks include it at 70% in the calculation. That often changes everything.

Thank you for your feedback.

Do you think the banker will really go as far as calling in the loan if the rent comes in every month to the account without any issues?

And there are always the arguments of « I changed my mind » or « my transfer didn’t work out » etc.

Regarding my concern about the debt-to-income ratio, it comes from the fact that my current rent is 755 euros including charges on a salary of 2,100 euros net, which significantly impacts my borrowing capacity for the bank.

Whereas my monthly savings effort is much higher than the requested monthly payments (I make a monthly savings effort of 500 euros while the loan for my rental investment would be around 300 euros).

This explains why this technique could make it easier to get my loan approved than revealing my real situation.

As Laurent said, contractual risks are scary and real, but in practice I’ve never seen anyone this has happened to, let alone on a single purchase

I’m here to moderate the discussion.

The demand for immediate repayment could occur if the bank has certainty of having been deceived, as in the case of a duplicate loan for example. In that case, it’s risky.

In your situation, you can very well change your project, have a child earlier, get divorced, be transferred, and it’s perfectly possible and legal to borrow for your primary residence (RP) which then becomes a rental investment. You will never be asked to repay everything at once.
However, if you have a PTZ (prêt à taux zéro - zero-interest loan) or an interest deferral linked to the « primary residence » status, the bank could apply interest on the entire loan, and you would be required to repay additional interest.

But for immediate repayment due to a change of project, really, that won’t happen.

1 Like

For your debt calculation: by saying RP, the bank removes your current €755 rent from the equation (you’re supposed to leave your apartment), and only considers the €300 loan. You go from ~50% to 14% debt ratio. That’s exactly why it works in your situation.

Rewol is right about the forfeiture. The real issue after that is the consistency of your file and your tax return the following year with the rental income.

1 Like

I did this myself a few years ago (declared it as a primary residence for the bank, then rented it out).

I agree with what Rewol mentioned — if there’s no specific provision in your loan agreement regarding a primary residence or any requirement to maintain it as a primary residence, nothing obliges you to keep it as such for the entire duration of the loan.

I’d even say that if it was never actually declared as a primary residence because you rented it out immediately, the bank doesn’t really have much to do with it. Change of plans between signing the loan offer and signing at the notary’s office, and that’s it.

In my case, it was the broker himself (a large brokerage chain, not a small independent broker) who recommended I do it that way, and I even think the bank strongly suspected it because my purchase didn’t make much sense as a primary residence: there were two of us, married, renting a 3-room flat in a nice building, with fairly comfortable salaries, and we were buying a small 30m² 2-room flat in a village further from our respective jobs… I even took out the landlord insurance with the same bank before signing at the notary’s office :rofl: (This was 6 years ago).