Optimizing an investment after some beginner mistakes

Hello everyone,

This message is to ask for your informed opinion on a wealth management strategy that I seem to have embarked on somewhat poorly, or at least one that doesn’t really offer me the clarity I was hoping for.

Situation: 49 years old

Income: 70k monthly

My portfolio is distributed as follows:

Linxea life insurance: 12k in euro funds

Lucya Cardiff life insurance: 12k of which - 60% boosted euro funds, the rest distributed between:

  • amundi smart overnight RET etf Acc: schelcher flexible short 2 duration; amundi FI rt Corp Bd ESG

Linxea PER: 12k

PEA: 15k with amundi DCAM and my old configuration (10%) in SP500, Japan and Europe

Livret A and LDDS full.

I need to keep liquidity for a potential real estate project within 1-3 years. But overall I find my positioning very defensive and quite unproductive, because it lacks direction. Do you see how to best allocate all this? I can’t shift everything to world ETFs, as the PEA has a 10/15 year horizon. The PER is only used for tax optimization. And the life insurance policies initially had a transmission function, but I’ve started to consider them as more favorable savings accounts…

Your allocation is, « unfortunately, » entirely compatible with your short-term real estate project: it secures the capital (well, if the government doesn’t decide to look for money where it is, a conspiracy theorist would say) at the cost of performance.
Given your age, you still have time to prepare for the transfer, since you may need the money from the life insurance policies (AV) to provide the down payment for a real estate purchase. However, the boosted fund still allows you to earn more than inflation.
Only the PEA (Plan d’Épargne en Actions) potentially allows you to add some performance to your wealth. Put all the savings capacity you won’t need for your purchase into it.

Hello

We don’t have enough information about your plans and your situation (primary residence? Renter?) Your income, the 70k is that monthly or annual?

Hello, it’s 70k annually and tenant for the rest!

Reading your post, I was wondering why you had so little savings at 70k monthly at your age, or maybe I’m thinking you’re a politician pulling a Darmanin on us with €300 in your current account and the rest hidden who knows where :grin:

Otherwise your investments look good (even though we don’t know what’s in the PER), as you say it’s very defensive, so for the change it’s quite simple, progressive DCA reinforced on your S&P 500, Japan and Europe. No need to risk the money already invested that you’ll need.

It’s often the dilemma in investing, we want performance but without the risk, and these two desires are incompatible. Consider the slider this way, you have two assets: secure funds / Growth assets, the rest is just a matter of the slider.

70/30?

60/40?

50/50?

It depends on your loss tolerance, for my mom I had her do 50% stocks/40% euro funds/10% gold to keep it simple for her to understand while seeking a bit of performance, but that already carries a risk of at least -25% potential in case of a major crisis. I myself am at 50% stocks/12.5 metals and energy/37.5% guaranteed vehicles.

I’m exaggerating a bit on guaranteed vehicles :grin: But it’s evolving if there’s a big drop in the other two categories I buy more by drawing from it. Then I « reload » the vehicles quietly. The idea is really to define a target allocation and not deviate from it even in the storm, the rest matters little. Otherwise there’s no mystery > more performance = more global stocks in ETF format.

Ahah I like your approach!

Well, the explanation is more about life’s ups and downs and the good things that sometimes come late! Which explains why I have little savings. And precisely, I have little time to catch up on things :slight_smile:

So on the PEA should I keep the USA/Europe/Japan triplet in addition to the DCAM? I’ll keep this idea of bringing the security portion to 60% and perhaps increasing the risk a bit!

I’ve seen here and there other people a bit lost between AVs and PEAs which share roughly the same possibilities. We’re wary of unnecessary duplicates

For gold, is it better to find it on AV with an Amundi gold? Or on PEA?

Well, the explanation has more to do with life’s ups and downs and the good things that sometimes come late! Which explains why I have little savings. And precisely. I have little time to catch up :slight_smile:

I wasn’t criticizing your savings, far from it and I wouldn’t presume to. On the contrary, your savings are already good, but you had written « 70k monthly, » which is almost 1 million per year in income, so that really didn’t add up :grin:

On the PEA should I keep the USA/Europe/Japan trio in addition to the Dcam? I’ll keep this idea of bringing safety to 60% and perhaps increasing risk a bit!

Both options are pretty much the same. I would simplify to a single dcam line. Even though personally I have Japan and my exotic stuff on life insurance.

But be careful, I’m saying this for mental comfort, in reality there’s no obligation to remove them.

Yes, go ahead cautiously, it’s respecting your risk tolerance that matters, you need to feel comfortable whatever happens. Get to the stage of: « I don’t care if it goes up or down. » 20/80, 30/70, 40/60, 50/50. Run catastrophe scenarios for yourself. e.g.: what happens if my 20% stocks lose -50%? I lose -10%, is that acceptable to me? -20% at 40/60. Assuming the markets don’t experience a crisis worse than COVID.

I’ve seen here and there other people a bit lost between life insurance and PEAs which share roughly the same possibilities. We fear useless duplicates

Nothing prevents you from having the same product on different brokers, for example I have a world etf on bourso and an msci global world on fortuneo, but it’s just to not put everything in pea. It’s not mentally optimal. We call that « having dust, » it’s better to have all your capital grouped in a single etf than in the same etf duplicated elsewhere, it allows for more fluid management.

For gold is it better to find it on life insurance with an Amundi gold? Or on PEA.

There’s no gold on pea, there are mining companies with basic materials or commodities that can play the same role, but no real paper gold.

For my part I prefer it in cto because of the Sapin law and the fact that if the insurer goes bankrupt we don’t see the securities again, but otherwise yes, in life insurance it can work. I have a bit in life insurance too.

CTO saxo or TR? I admit I had put the CTO « for later » but maybe that’s a mistake.

I had a gold certificate on AV Lucya and I gave it up (high fees). But gold or mining could be interesting!

So I could simplify:

One Dcam line in PEA

An evolution of the AV with a split between euro funds/UC where I could go for an ACWI ETF or find my triplet Japan/US/Europe again

A CTO with gold/mining?

I have

Forgot the PER is with Linxea in piloted mode with a target horizon. I find the return rather average. Even though I have a « dynamic » profile, it remains at 4/10 on the risk scale and generates a small 2.5%.

TR is top. XTB 0 fees but no fractions. Saxo I don’t have. My favorite is trading 212 but it’s going to be tough for taxes because no tax statement… TR would therefore be the most flexible that I would recommend to everyone. In scheduled plan 0 fees on top of that.

  • Yes one line, always favor simplicity.

Given your setup (you have all the bonds on linxea), to stay consistent, open a TR CTO and put a gold or global mining ETF in it indeed. That way the role of each wrapper will be clear.

For the PER I can’t answer you I don’t know their composition.

For the SP500, Europe, Japan case. It’s the biggest effort. But you need to think in terms of asset nature, they’re all stocks, which the PEA world already provides. Then it’s also possible not to do a single dcam and keep all 3, it’s a bit more annoying.

Stats of the 3 over 5 years:

In blue it’s the S&P 500 and orange Japan, we can see that the gray which is the MSCI world is always the best compromise. So in summary that the others are useless over a 5-year period, it will just reduce the overall average by a few points :slight_smile:

I’m having trouble letting go of Japan out of conviction and the S&P 500 because it always slightly outperforms the world. Thank you for the advice on the CTO, and for all your very clear answers, it makes things more understandable for me.