I found this structure labeled ESUS (a French label for the social and solidarity economy). Investing in this type of structure allows for a 25% reduction on taxes next year, in exchange for a 7-year lock-up period and a risk of capital loss and illiquidity.
The idea is to become the banker for people who don’t have access to bank credit (too old or they’ve reached the maximum debt level accepted by banks), but only for energy renovation work on their homes. In exchange, the real estate company becomes owner of a share of the property. After renovation, the property improves on the DPE (energy performance diagnosis) and therefore increases in value. The share was revalued by 4% at the last two AGMs. This needs to be added to the benefit from the tax reduction (which is around 2.85% according to my IRR calculations with an exit assumption at 7.5 years, net of fees).
I’m interested in the ESG aspects of my investments and this one would be at the top of my ranking because with the rising cost of energy and the uncertainties around Ma Prime Rénov’ (French renovation subsidy program), there must be real demand.
Has anyone already invested with them? Any opinions?
I have invested in it, yes, because it’s a project that really resonates with me! I only have 2 years of experience with it, so I can’t tell you much more than that I’m satisfied with it!
I haven’t invested with them but I looked at their model. The 25% income tax reduction is really the driver of the IRR, without it you’re looking at a risky investment for a very low return.
What concerns me is the exit: you depend on the revaluation of shares at the AGM over 7 years, with no guaranteed visibility. With direct rental property using bank leverage you have more control over the asset and generally better IRRs.
That said, if the ESG angle is a real priority for you, it can make sense as diversification. Not as a main investment.
Indeed, without the ESUS advantage, we’d be at 0.7\**\~4%* = 2.5% net of tax.
And yes, I have no guarantee of being able to exit directly after 7 years. But same as with SCPI!
If it drags on to 8 years, it will lower my IRR a bit, by 0.3% according to my calculations. I calculate that it would still give me 5.3% net of tax (if it continues to be revalued at 4% per year). Let’s say 5% net is my psychological limit
No, not as a primary investment. The amount is limited anyway by the taxes I pay.
This seems like a reasoned approach, especially if you’re actually limited by the amount of taxes you pay. That’s where this type of vehicle makes the most sense. The only unknown remains the 4% annual revaluation, which depends on the general meetings and the actual performance of the REIT. If it stagnates or declines, your IRR takes a hit. But for this kind of limited amount, the risk/return ratio remains reasonable.